Britain Defies U.S. on Gag Rule

I t is obvious that nothing good is happening domestically on reproductive rights. Internationally, however, a small bright spot appeared in mid-February when Britain’s Department for International Development announced that it would contribute $5.3 million to organizations that have been denied family planning money because of the Mexico City policy, i.e., the Global Gag Rule. 

According to Population Action International (PAI), the Gag Rule, first imposed by Ronald Reagan in 1984, rescinded by Bill Clinton in 1993, and re-imposed by George W. Bush in 2001, has forced some family planning clinics to close and has led to staff reduction and cutbacks as well as fee hikes for reproductive health services throughout much of the world. In addition, PAI reports that “family planning organizations that reject the Gag Rule have been unable to obtain donated contraceptives on which the women and men they serve depend.” PAI researchers also found that in the five years since Bush reinstituted the Gag Rule, numerous countries have seen their healthcare referral networks collapse. Furthermore, reductions in technical assistance, as well as the loss of condoms previously supplied by U.S. agencies, have had a deleterious impact not just on pregnancy rates, but on STD transmission. 

British Development Minister Gareth Thomas told the press that the grant would provide start-up funds to the Global Safe Abortion Program developed by the International Planned Parenthood Federation (IPPN). The need, he announced, is blatant and replacing lost financing for reproductive healthcare has been long in coming. Thomas described the more than 19 million illegal abortions that occur worldwide each year and told reporters that between 70,000 and 76,000 women, most of them young and poor, die from sepsis and hemorrhaging directly linked to unsafe surgeries. “The Global Safe Abortion Program will work to support abortion and improve access to abortion services and will help those groups that have been forced to cut back on reproductive health services,” he said. “Maternal deaths represent one of the starkest indicators of inequality within, and between, rich and poor nations. Much more must be done to ensure that those most vulnerable have access to the care and services they need.” 

The Gag Rule has long rankled international activists because it prohibits the State Department and USAID, the world’s largest financier of family planning and women’s health services, from giving monies to non-governmental organizations that perform abortions—unless the abortion is needed to save the pregnant woman’s life or is to end a pregnancy resulting from rape or incest—or that counsel women about their options or refer them to abortion providers. Organizations that accept money from the U.S. are further barred from lobbying to make abortion legal or working to make the procedure more accessible in nations where it is already lawful. 

“Family planning is a key entry point for many women to health care,” says Shirine Mohagheghpour, assistant director of Planned Parenthood Global Partners. This is why she and her colleagues are thrilled by Britain’s decision. Furthermore, she is delighted that Britain is stepping in to fill the gap because Britain is typically seen as a U.S. ally. “This is an interesting challenge to the U.S., a very public slap in the face. Britain is saying, ‘We cannot abide by women dying from the lack of family planning.’ Because of the strong relationship between Britain and the U.S. government on other fronts, this is a fascinating distancing move,” she says. 

Mohagheghpour recently returned from Africa where she witnessed the importance of contraceptives in people’s everyday lives. “Everything in Africa is so interconnected,” she says. “I saw how the drought in Tanzania is exacerbated by more births, how a higher birthrate means that more people are impacted by the water crisis. All over Africa women are dying from too many unintended pregnancies and as a consequence of illegal or unsafe abortions.”