Iranian Detention of US Activist, Journalist Nears Two-Year Mark
July 31st marks exactly two years since Iranian authorities seized three Americans - Shane Bauer, Sarah Shourd, and Josh Fattal - in the mountains of Iraqi Kurdistan and falsely accused them of espionage on behalf of the US government. All three are progressive, anti-imperialist activists, which not only makes the charges against them particularly absurd, but also may explain why the Obama administration has done so little to free them.
Shourd was released last September and returned to the United States, but Bauer and Fattal remain imprisoned, and are scheduled to finally go to trial on the second anniversary of their arrest. They were given a few hours in court back in February, at which they submitted long written statements and their not-guilty pleas. Since then, there have been no additional proceedings. Several dates for the trial have been set, and then cancelled without explanation. The two have still not been allowed to have even a brief meeting with their lawyer.
Portrait of Three Activists
Bauer, Shourd, and Fattal were graduates of the University of California at Berkeley and were well known in the antiwar movement in the Bay Area. Fattal's major passions were sustainable agriculture, food justice and permaculture, which he pursued at the Aprovecho Research Center in Oregon. Just prior to visiting Bauer and Shourd, he had been serving as a teaching fellow with the International Honors Program's Health and Community project, spending time in Switzerland, India, China and South Africa. While a student at Berkeley, he was a leader in the movement to get military recruiters off campus.
With support from the Investigative Fund of The Nation Institute and the Center for Investigative Reporting, Bauer was working as a freelance journalist in various countries in the Middle East, exposing a number of aspects of US policy in the region that Washington would rather keep quiet. Along with his friend Dahr Jamail, he was one of the few independent journalists in Baghdad. His 2009 article "Iraq's New Death Squad" in The Nation magazine revealed how Iraq Special Operations Forces (ISOF), the largest foreign Special Forces outfit ever developed by the United States, was engaged in widespread human rights abuses. An article he wrote for Mother Jones just months before his capture revealed how the US government, in an effort to bring temporary stability to Iraq, funneled billions of dollars to what he referred to as, "the country's next generation of strongmen." At the time of his arrest, Bauer was finishing a major investigative article on the illegal use by Israeli occupation forces of "nonlethal" weapons, such as the "long-range teargas canister" (which essentially acts as a missile), against nonviolent protesters. During the past two years, such weapons killed Bassem Abu Rahmah, a leading Palestinian nonviolent activist, and have grievously injured scores of others, including Americans Tristan Anderson and Emily Henochowicz.
Shourd was teaching English as a volunteer with the Iraqi Student Project, which was set up to help refugees whose education had been interrupted by the US invasion and occupation. Among her projects was helping some of the more promising young exiles to obtain scholarships at American universities. Before leaving the United States, Shourd was living in Oakland, where she was an organizer in support of immigrant rights, including the historic May Day marches of 2006. She also facilitated groups to the US-Mexican border to challenge the Minutemen and other nativist vigilantes. Prior to moving to the Middle East, Shourd spent time in the Mexican state of Chiapas doing solidarity work with the Zapatistas. Her blogs on the ongoing repression by both the Mexican and Israeli governments were well received by human rights activists.
While in Oakland, both Shourd and Bauer were part of the Midnight Special Law Collective, which provides legal and other support for activists around the country. Along with Fattal, they were actively involved with Direct Action to Stop the War in organizing nonviolent action campaigns against the US occupation of Iraq. They also volunteered for the Common Ground Collective's efforts to support rebuilding poor sections of New Orleans devastated by Hurricane Katrina based upon the principle of "solidarity, not charity."
On moving to Syria in 2008, Shourd and Bauer chose to live in a Palestinian refugee camp and engage in Palestine solidarity work. When Israeli occupation forces shot their friend, Anderson, in the head during a nonviolent protest in the West Bank, they went to visit him in an Israeli hospital, just three weeks before their kidnapping.
Iraqi Kurdistan is generally considered to be a safe place for Western tourists. The mountains there are among the most beautiful in the world, so it's not surprising that young Americans familiar with the Middle East would want to explore the area. Unfortunately, the Bush administration had used these same mountains to arm PJAK, a militant separatist group of Iranian Kurds closely aligned with the PKK, the notorious Turkish Kurdish militia. Obama suspended the clandestine effort within days of coming to office in 2009 and appropriately declared PJAK a terrorist group.
The Bush administration may also have sent US Special Forces to the region to infiltrate Iran in preparation of a major US attack - as revealed in a series of articles by Seymour Hersh - a practice also apparently suspended by the Obama administration. Given this recent history, claims of infiltration by American agents in this border region can appear plausible to many Iranians. In many respects, then, the continued captivity of Bauer and Fattal is yet another tragic legacy of the Bush administration.
The destination of the three hikers was the Ahmed Awa waterfall, an area popular among Iraqis and a growing number of Western tourists. The spot was highly recommended by locals, but none of the three Americans apparently knew that it was so close to the Iranian border. Though the Iranian regime claims they crossed into Iranian territory, eyewitnesses say they were seized inside Iraq by Iranian guards who illegally crossed the border and effectively kidnapped them. Indeed, theRevolutionary Guard officer who apparently ordered their abduction has since been arrested on suspicion of smuggling, kidnapping and murder. In short, despite such characterizations in the media, these were hardly "hapless hikers" who naively walked into Iran.
Disparity in Coverage
The fate of these two activists has not received the amount of attention the media gave to Iranian-American journalist Roxana Saberi, who was detained for three months on espionage charges by the Iranian regime, or of journalists Lisa Ling and Euna Lee, who were freed after four months in captivity by the North Koreans following intervention by former president Bill Clinton. A number of right-wing bloggers, labeling the hikers as "anti-Israel" and "far-left," have argued that the State Department should just "let 'em rot."
Perhaps as a testament to his own youthful idealism as a community organizer, President Barack Obama acknowledged their activism in a statement calling for their release, saying, "They are simply open-minded and adventurous young people who represent the best of America, and of the human spirit. They are teachers, artists and advocates for social and environmental justice." Overall, however, the Obama administration appears to place freeing them from Iranian captivity as a relatively low priority.
After working unsuccessfully through official channels for the first ten months of their captivity, some of the friends and family members of the detainees decided to publicize their plight - along with their history of activism - in the hopes that global civil society, particularly the progressive activist community, would take the kind of initiative not yet coming from Washington. Within months, Shourd was freed. However, the campaign has not grown as fast as many had hoped, even as a concern over the health and safety of Bauer and Fattal has grown.
The fearmongering and saber-rattling that US hawks have directed at the Iranian regime make it difficult for some progressive activists in the United States to speak out against the repression of the right-wing theocratic regime in Tehran. Yet, while the military threat posed by Iran is often greatly exaggerated, the repressive nature of the regime is not. Indeed, the absurd notion that these three progressive, anti-imperialist activists would be spying for the US government is but one more demonstration of the moral and political bankruptcy of the Iranian government. And, given that - despite all the extreme anti-Iranian rhetoric - Washington is not doing much in support of these American captives, it's up the progressive community to organize on their behalf.
Leading progressives such as intellectuals Noam Chomsky and Cornel West, activist-scholar Angela Davis, antiwar activist Cindy Sheehan, Codepink cofounder Medea Benjamin, journalists Alex Cockburn and Christian Parenti, and the late historian Howard Zinn have called for their release. As Chomsky put it, "These young people represent a segment of the US population that is critical of [U.S.] policies, and often actively opposed to them. Hence their detention is particularly distressing to all of us who are dedicated to shifting US policy to one of mutual respect rather than domination."
For More Information
A petition is posted at www.freethehikers.org, which also posts ways to send letters to US and Iranian officials and learn how to help organize actions to protest Bauer and Fattal's detention and demand their release. Another web site, which focuses primarily on their activism and includes links to their writings, can be found at: freeourfriends.eu. For information on this month's campaign calling on people to contact the Iranian interest section in Washington in the lead-up to the trial, contact http://twoyearsistoolong.wordpress.com.
Stephen Zunes is a professor of politics and international studies at the University of San Francisco, where he chairs the program in Middle Eastern Studies.