To:

Zcom_simple
Home » ZMag » Z magazine Readers » Letters to the Editor
113_medium

June 2008

Volume 21, Number 6
Activism

Mississippi’s SB 2988
David Bacon


StratCom
Bruce k. Gagnon


A War on Communities
Cynthia Peters


Commentary

Letters
Z magazine Readers


Campaign Issues
Lydia Sargent


Aircraft Maintenance
Carl Finamore


Racial Profiling
Margaret Kwoka


Sean Bell Verdict
Rosa Clemente


Religious Right
Bill Berkowitz


Water Crisis
Alex Stonehill


Culture

Damming the Flood
Ben Terrall


Review: Takeover
Jeffrey Frank


Features

Triumph of Lunacy
Edward Herman


Dr. Wall Street
Jeremy Brecher


Market Madness
A.k. Gupta


Financial Crisis and Financialization's Appropriations
William Tabb


Epic Recession?
Jack Rasmus


Colombia Trade Deal
Roger Bybee


Zaps

Zaps
Various submissions


NOTE: Z Magazine subscribers and sustainers have access to all Z Magazine articles here and in the archive. The latest Z Magazine articles available to everyone are listed in the Free Articles box at the top of the table of contents, and are starred in the list below. Questions? e-mail Z Magazine Online.

Letters to the Editor

By Z magazine Readers
PDF Version
Printer Friendly Version
June 2008
 Change Text Size a- | A+

 

 

Tibet 

The Dalai Lama says he and George W. Bush are like "two old friends." The CIA is also quite friendly with the Dalai Lama. That's why they financed the 1959 uprising in Tibet and paid a regular stipend to the Dalai Lama and his supporters for many years afterward. Even today, much of the funding for the Dalai Lama and the Free Tibet movement comes from the CIA through the National Endowment for Democracy. 

The Dalai Lama claims he has "no hidden agenda." Perhaps not, but can we say the same for Bush and the CIA? What's really going on in Tibet? 

Our first impulse as progressives is to support these Buddhist protesters and Tibetan independence. (I thought their banner drop on the Golden Gate Bridge was pretty cool.) However, the Bush/Pelosi/CIA connection makes us think more carefully. If you google "Tibet" you will find hundreds of hits supporting the Free Tibet movement. However, if you google "Dalai Lama CIA" or "CIA Tibet" you find abundant documentation of CIA involvement in Tibet and a different point of view, with thoughtful articles by Michael Parenti, "Friendly Feudalism: The Tibet Myth," "The Green Left," "The Dalai Lama's hidden past," and Richard M Bennett, "Tibet, the ‘great game' and the CIA." Then, try googling "Lee Siu Hin Tibet," "PSL Tibet," and "Workers World Tibet." Along the way, you'll come across Tom Grunfeld's authoritative The Making of Modern Tibet. 

These sources raise significant questions about the Tibetan independence movement. For example, the media suggest that premodern Tibet ruled by the lamas was a peaceful, deeply spiritual country. But was this really the case? Or was it a brutal feudal theocracy, totally lacking in religious freedom, political freedom, and human rights as suggested by Parenti and numerous other sources? 

The media talks about the Chinese "takeover" or "invasion" of Tibet. But has Tibet ever been independent? Or has it been part of China for centuries? No modern nation has recognized Tibet as an independent nation, nor does the United Nations. Tibet is part of China, the Tibet Autonomous Region (TAR). Tibetans are recognized as one of over 50 national minority groups in the Peoples Republic of China and by no means the largest. Not all ethnic Tibetans live in the TAR, and dozens of other national minorities also live in the TAR. 

The media talks about "cultural genocide" in Tibet. But were the Tibetan masses better off when the Dalai Lama and the feudal landlords were in power? There were no public schools or hospitals in pre-modern Tibet. According to PRC statistics, infant mortality has dropped from 430 to less than 25 deaths per 1,000 births, literacy has dramatically improved, and the number of hospital beds and medical personnel in Tibet exceeds China's per capita national average. Further, the one-child rule imposed on Han Chinese families is relaxed for Tibetans and other national minorities.  How does this relate to charges of genocide by the Chinese against the Tibetans? 

Most troubling of all, of course, is the role of the CIA and ruling class figures such as George Soros. Is the U.S. still playing the "great game" in Central Asia? Does China have to fear a Kosovo-style "humanitarian" intervention by the United States? Crazy? Perhaps. But remember when Brze- zinski and the CIA starting funding the Mujahadeen in Afghanistan in 1979, thus prompting the Soviets to send troops? Who would have thought the U.S. would have troops and bases in Central Asia within 30 years. As you investigate these questions more thoroughly, you might start wondering whether the Free Tibet movement is something progressives really want to support. 

- Eugene E Ruyle
Long Beach, CA 

The Right Side of Italy 

Berlusconi is back. With his virtual smiles and real lies. With his selfish practices, awkward jokes and colorful cheerleaders. If its "Party of Liberty" counts 56 condemned criminals (including himself) and barred offenders, why should it matter? Fraud, corruption, mafia connections: all can be forgiven. In the name of profit. In the gospel of power. That is all the Italian consumers needed after all. And the public? It is gone and done. Silvio won. That is all now that matters. The rest it is idle chatter. He did not need a "coup." A march to Rome. He simply seized the collective mind. Good night and good luck Italy. The Berlusconian nightmare must go on. Do not wake up too soon. 

- Roberto De Vogli
London, UK 

Signing Statements 

Hi...outraged one more time, after reading Bob Elmendorf's "A Judicial Irony." Thanks for publishing this article, however upsetting. I submitted it to the news reading/analyzing  service of which I am a member called News Trust in hopes this info would reach a larger audience. It would be great for anyone of the editors to check News Trust, helping to debunk some of the drivel pawned off as news. 

- Ben
Hamden, CT 

Phoenix Rising 

Aword of appreciation for Roberto  J. González and "A Phoenix Rising?" I hope Z in the future will continue to follow related themes. One came to mind while I read the article: the corruption of professional organizations by employment of large numbers of members of the military. I heard that the recent meetings of the American Psychological Association failed to pass a resolution against psychologists participating in torture. Large numbers of military psychologists attended the meetings. Gonzalez doesn't mention that as a current problem for the American Anthropological Association, but we ought to consider the motives of the military in hiring social scientists. My sense is that American society's most prevalent social-psychological disease is militarism and we may be so deeply infected that only social scientists from other countries would have sufficient objectivity to study the penetration of militarism into our psyche. 

- Dale Berry
Grants, NM

 

 

Send letters to Z Magazine to zmag@zmag.org, or to Z Magazine, 18 Millfield St., Woods Hole, MA 02543; fax 508-457-0626.

 

 

 

 

 

Loading_border