Loving Your Job When You Really Hate It
By Justin George at Feb 25, 2008 |
|
In less than two weeks time
As part of the move I’ve had to hand in my resignation, doing so was an interesting experience. Its amazing how much one develops Stockholm Syndrome with one's employer. While I’ve tried to challenge and improve office life and policies, subverting when I can, I think you can’t help but form a weird love/hate relationship to the place where you spend most of your life. I can’t imagine what that would be like for someone who has had a job with the same company for 30 years or more. The sensation is unusual and I feel adds an understanding in some ways to the 'stickiness' problem that Albert has discussed in relation to radical politics and movement building.
Everyday I loathe being forced to sit under artificial light, virtually chained to a computer, for 8 hours a day. But come the time to quit and a fear of being without a safety net starts influencing my reasoning, suddenly the job's 'not that bad' , or 'I won't find better' and suddenly Im in the same position for another 6 months swallowing more of the same old crap. I think this reflects how dependent people can feel towards the exploiters. I know how I am being used, I could see through the managers corp. speak yet, I know of alternatives yet I felt compelled to go along. That didnt mean I didnt try and stir up worker anger when promises weren’t met by management or that I didnt create my little pocket of resistance even if that just meant reading ZNet on the company's dollar. But in the end I went along as I felt I needed a job. What I also found interesting is that the more you earn the more you get tied up into the system. I went from an unemployed student on welfare eating cans of beans but having enough to pay the bills, to a part time job then to a full time job and a promotion and I found that no matter the paycheck I was spending the excess. That rather than living on cans of beans still, extra cash meant that I could buy marinated tofu, a CD or go see a movie, or subscribe to ZMag and suddenly I was much more dependent on keeping my job to ensure that I could continue to enjoy the things that I built up around me- good and bad. So its interesting in finally leaving how hard it can be for people to give up that feeling of security, of having a safety net, even though most people know the system is not working for them. Another aspect of leaving is moving on from your workmates. While I definitely dont like everyone I work with, in general there is a sense of solidarity that develops among people, that we're all in the same boat together. So in some ways it feels that by leaving you're escaping while they have to endure, which for me isn't a pleasant feeling.
So these are some of my feelings about moving on to something new and hopefully more fulfilling. I think that my feelings might give some indication to some of the similar feelings many people have when it comes to work, worker exploitation and capitalism in general. Often I read that people need to know that TINA (there is no alternative) is not the case. While that is true, I feel that often people know that there is an alternative, its the fear of leaving what little (if any) bit if security they have in order to try the alternative. For me I know that there is an alternative yet I found it very hard to move away from the system in a small way, let alone seek out new ways of structuring and organizing our world. That’s not to say that I dont agree with struggling for such change, what Im saying is that perhaps its not only TINA we have to fight, but also the ways that people cling on to the system with the mentality of 'I only have a little bit here but its better than nothing if change doesn’t work'
So as movements we might also need to find ways that make people feel secure, to embrace change, to feel that moving towards a radical change such a Parecon is not such a big leap it just requires everyone to take at least one step in the same direction. We need to not only let people know that there are alternatives but that such alternatives are worth giving up the little scraps thrown their way by those with money and power. How we can counter feelings of insecurity and fear, and ways we can help overcome working people's Stockholm Syndrome Im not sure, but I feel that we must include such considerations when we organize and promote radical alternatives. In doing so we might be more effective in attracting and retaining active people in progressive movements, people able to end their abusive relationships with their exploiters, and move ahead for the change for a more fulfilling and enjoyable world.



Re: Loving Your Job When You Really Hate It
By Small, Brian at May 01, 2009 01:54 AM
Justin, best of luck with the move and job change. I hope you don't have to go back to only canned beans and can keep eating tofu, and local organic veggies - we need those omega 3 fats. I had issues with a previous job in a corporate English Conversation school over and above the night schedule - but it was still hard to leave the people I worked with. Tearful. I have a good job, comparatively now, but would feel more fulfilled creating a new institution like South End Press, Zcom or something. Maybe a Community Polyface Farms or something. A lot of locals I talk with feel the same way but I don't think anyone feels able to take responsibility for our livelihoods starting up an institution from scratch. That's why the Basic Income proposals presented by young Japanese activists struck such a cord with me recently. Maybe this is what would free up some space for people to dedicate themselves to self-motivate, fulfilling work. That will be a fairly long political struggle I imagine. In the meantime how about some kind of participatory Zbank where we all invest in Z contributor projects and initiatives. These NPO or citizen banks have been picking up steam in Japan. The idea could end up fomenting the kind of mutual aid organization Kropotkin and Bakunin are supposed to have started up wherevere they got to... Just got starte brainstorming, sorry.
Reply this comment
Re: Loving Your Job When You Really Hate It
By Schindler, Jonathan at Feb 12, 2009 10:13 AM
This article reminds me of a thought I once had about
Reply this comment
Loving what you do
By Schindler, Jonathan at Feb 12, 2009 10:20 AM
Reply this comment
Re: Loving Your Job When You Really Hate It
By B./r./o./d./i./e, P./a./u./l at Feb 28, 2008 02:49 AM
I liked this piece. I have to watch myself sometimes, as I often find myself identifying with my boss\' interests, understanding and making room for his needs instead of thinking "hey, I sacrifice more than you, why should you get more?"
The basic psychological dynamic between employer and worker isn\'t much different, if at all, from chattel slavery. For the worker, it\'s degrading and you know it but yet you instinctively make do with the situation you have.
Maybe this is stockholm syndrome in action now, but I think my boss is probably suffering more at the hands of capitalism than I am. He works longer despite his greater income, and in many ways the material benefits he accrues are not compensating for the psychological negatives that come from worrying about business and money all day. Further, because on the surface he has more than I have, he will probably be more attached to capitalism than an alternative, even though capitalism is doing him more damage than I.
It\'s as though once one has consciously invested considerable energy in "getting ahead" within the confines of this system, one does not want to contemplate the thought that "getting ahead" not as fulfilling as it was made out, nor does one want to contemplate an alternative such as parecon. It would be an conscious admission to oneself that one has gone down the wrong track.
This might also be a big obstacle. Not the recognition from co-ordinators that parecon might be better (even for them) than capitalism, but having to invalidate all one\'s previous efforts and energies that were used previously to get ahead within the confines of capitalism.
Reply this comment
All together too...
By Davis, Connie at Feb 26, 2008 00:31 AM
I really appreciated this article and have that same working peoples \'stockholm syndrome\'.
I know I\'ve grown attached to all the stuff I can buy with my income, and dread being layed off or fired even though I hate many aspects of my job as well. I\'ve ran that scenario in my head and take comfort in the fact that I have a very supportive family that can help me out if I get in a bind. Others may not be as lucky as I, so I agree a radical change to Parecon would need some form of solid assurance for the working poor who have no family to fall back on.
I hope your move to Melbourne goes well.... C.D.
Reply this comment
Re: All together too...
By Small, Brian at May 01, 2009 00:51 AM
Connie Davis wrote
>Others may not be as lucky as I, so I agree a radical change to Parecon would need some form of solid assurance for the working poor who have no family to fall back on.
I think this is why the 'Basic Income' proposal attracts me so much. It would free more people up to experiment, change their situation a bit... I remember waiting in a convenience store to buy a hoagie with some construction workers and one said 'it don't matter what you do, you do it every day it gets old.' Balanced job complexes would be welcome to a lot of people.
http://www.basicincome.org/bien/aboutbasicincome.html
http://www.usbig.net/whatisbig.html
http://www.citizensincome.org/resources/newsletter%20issue%202%202009.shtml/#Namibia
Reply this comment
All Together
By Carter, Joseph at Feb 25, 2008 19:19 PM
I envy your spirit and your coming adventure. The hope remains for my wife and I to cut away from this mess some day and move to Europe or Canada somewhere with less "Game Theory" in our every day lives. Good luck in Melbourne las I understand the big city is absolutely beautiful. Keep blogging during your adventure.
Joe
Reply this comment