My First Peace Demonstration - The Realities of Protesting in Israel
By Tali Shapiro at Jan 10, 2009 |
|
Today I went to my first demonstration, organized by the Hadash party and the organization "Peace Now". It was a small peace rally in front of the Ministry of Defense building, in Tel Aviv. I was exited to go and felt it was important I take this step. I'd love to say it was filled with adrenalin and inspirational, but the truth is rather disappointing. Here's a short video I nicked off the Hadash website:
The Protestors
Despite Hadash's reports of a thousand people, it'd be optimistic of me to estimate 300 when I was there. Most were standing quietly, and a minority was raising their voices a bit, to say the slogans.
Heavy Police Presence
To the protestors' defense, the police presence was huge! It'd be fair to say there was a ratio of at least 1 officer for every 2 protestors.
As you walk up the street to the Ministry of Defense square, there are officers all the way along the street. The square is fenced with mobile barriers and a dense group of police cars, police officers and military police officers stand about two meters (about 6 and a half feet) from it and look on.
For me, the biggest eye openers were the jail van, parking on the sidewalk, doors open and ready to go. The other thing was explained to me by a friend of mine, who has been going to protests with his father since he was about 15, who was kind enough to give me the grand tour:
"You see the guys with the leather jackets and no badges? Those are the ones that pound you. If we weren't in the middle of Tel Aviv, their faces would be covered with motorcycle helmets."
Dispersing as Quickly as Possible
Less than an hour into the demonstration a megaphone sounds, politely asking everyone to "gather all the banners near the stage and disperse."
The Media
On the way- to and back- from the demonstration I heard the hourly, 5 minute segment of the news on the radio. It was the same every time, 3rd-5th item (to the best of my translation):
"A Peace Now rally, of a few hundreds, against the war is being held outside the Ministry of Defense. The police is heavily distributed in the area, keeping the peace."
Apart from the obvious fallacy of portraying the police as a "protector of the peace", something else about this sentence bugs me: The newscaster never names Hadash as responsible for the protest. This creates the impression that this is not a protest that a part of the government is actually a part of.
My Personal Impression of My First Peace Demonstration
I was scared. As I walked up the street, to get to the demonstration, the long line of police officers were making negative comments and giving dirty looks. When I met my friend there, he had already bean harassed and threatened.
We left early, as my friend explained to me that those who left last week's March (over 10,000 people!) last, got beaten, by pro-war protestors (the creeps who come out only when peace protests are being held) and arrested by the police, their houses searched and computers confiscated. Fear was felt all around and a sense of urgency to leave as soon and as quietly as possible.
Here's an article from The Real News Network, to expand on the government pressure put on protests:



Better 300 than....
By Andrews, John at Jan 12, 2009 18:25 PM
Hi Tali
I salute you for attending an anti-war demonstration in Tel Aviv - that takes a lot of courage. Don't be disheartened by the small number - it will grow.
Here in London we had 100,000 protestors on the march but here...........things get confused.
I'm sure that 70% of the people on the march were for a ceasefire and wanted to stop, immediately, the bloodshed on pure humanitarian grounds. There were however plenty of people who were on the march demanding their sordid right to undertake honour killings, to keep woman in 'their rightful place' (in burqahs) and throw all the jews into the sea. This has been the way since the invasion of Iraq. In some respects, middle east protest here has been hijacked by the the right wing Islamists.
Looking back to the period between 1960 and 1990, the USA and Israel (and the west in general) supported the Islamists against nationalist/socialist/communist governments and politicians in Egypt, Algeria, Indonesia, Palestine, Pakistan and Afghanistan to name but a few. We are now all paying a hideous price for this stupidity of policy.
As a pacifist and an anarchist ( or possibly a socialist - I hope to sort out this internal conflict before I depart this mortal coil!), I cannot march with the fascists of Hamas / Islamic Jihad / Hizbollah or any of the rest of the Islamist Fascistic Army. Similary, I have no truck with the fascistic Israeli government.
Personally, I would rather be in the company of three hundred committed pacifists than what we have here in London. Numbers are not everything.
Keep safe and all best wishes.
Hasta la vista siempre.
John Andrews
Reply this comment
Re: Better 300 than....
By Shapiro, Tali at Jan 13, 2009 03:00 AM
Reply this comment
Re: My First Peace Demonstration - The Realities of Protesting in Israel
By Petridis, Athanasios at Jan 11, 2009 17:05 PM
Courage! It was like that here before and when the ivasion of Iraq started. There was no apparent violence against the peace activists but there was a lot of intimidation and misinformation by the media and the pro-war lobby. Those who supported peace were called "weak", "anti-american", even friends of terrorists. It is also interesting that in spite of the initial momentum very little is happening now in terms of protests and demostrations and the wars keep on.... Thanks for sharing your experience. We need to know what is going on there. - Athan
Reply this comment
Re:
By Shapiro, Tali at Jan 12, 2009 07:36 AM
Reply this comment
Re: Re:
By Petridis, Athanasios at Jan 12, 2009 15:08 PM
Reply this comment
Re: Re: Re:
By Shapiro, Tali at Jan 13, 2009 02:50 AM
Reply this comment
The user who created this comment no longer exists.