Volume , Number 0
Crime & Punishment
American Journalism: A Class Act
The United States in the â€¦
Stephen R. Shalom
Patriotism Is An Olympic Event
Differing Agendas in South Asia
Bryan g. Pfeifer
Bryan g. Pfeifer
Psychiatric Medications, Illicit Drugs, & â€¦
Martin Glaberman: 1918-2001
There are no articles.Culture
There are no articles.Features
Ruth hubbard and Stuart newman
There are no articles.
NOTE: Z Magazine subscribers and sustainers have access to all Z Magazine articles here and in the archive. The latest Z Magazine articles available to everyone are listed in the Free Articles box at the top of the table of contents, and are starred in the list below. Questions? e-mail Z Magazine Online.
Psychiatric Medications, Illicit Drugs, & Alcohol
The article titled “Pay Attention: Ritalin Acts Much Like Cocaine” was published in August 2001 in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA). It's not likely you've heard about it. Pharmaceutical companies do their best to ensure we hear something altogether different, something like this: “Psychiatric medication—just like insulin—restores the chemical imbalances that cause mental illness.” To get that message across, they spend billions of dollars on TV commercials. They also spend billions of dollars on drug representative visits to doctors' offices, advertisements in medical journals, and seminars for doctors. Pharmaceutical companies even help fund the American Psychiatric Association, the National Alliance for the Mentally Ill, and other mental health institutions. Nearly one in four American adults are taking prescription psychotropic drugs, while America's “war on drugs” has led to more people imprisoned in the United States (in total and per capita) than any other industrialized nation.
If psychiatric drugs are chemically similar to illicit drugs and alcohol, and if all of these substances are used for similar purposes, then hypocrisy has created two ongoing tragedies: (1) an unfair incarceration of millions of Americans (mostly poor and without health insurance) for using illicit drugs, and (2) a denial of the societal realities for why millions more Americans (mostly not poor and with health insurance) are using psychiatric drugs. Do psychiatric medications in fact restore chemical imbalances that cause mental illness? Are psychiatric medications analogous to insulin? Or are psychiatric drugs more like illicit drugs and alcohol?
While we know insulin can temporarily restore a chemical imbalance for a diabetic, we have no such scientific knowledge that any psychiatric drug restores a chemical imbalance for someone having emotional difficulties. We don't even have scientific proof that mental disorders are caused by chemical imbalances. In 1998 the National Institutes of Health acknowledged that there is no known chemical imbalance—or any known biological basis—for attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD); and in 2000 the American Academy of Pediatrics confirmed this. Your doctor will tell you that neither a lab test nor a physical exam is used to diagnose ADHD, which is in fact determined on the basis of behavior checklists. The chemical imbalance theory of ADHD is just that—a theory.
For years we've heard that depression was caused by neurotransmitter imbalances. We were told that depression was linked to too little norepinephrine, and that drugs like Tofranil and Elavil would restore this imbalance. But in the late 1980s, selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) such as Prozac (and later Zoloft and Paxil) hit the market. We were then told that depression was caused by too little serotonin. Recently, there's been a TV commercial blitz for a non-SSRI antidepressant Wellbutrin, which enhances the neurotransmitter dopamine. Why this jumping around? Science has not linked the cause of depression to any biochemical imbalance, as was made abundantly clear by Elliot Valenstein, professor emeritus of Neuroscience at the University of Michigan, in his book Blaming the Brain (1998). Comparing psychiatric drugs to insulin is like comparing apples to oranges. No one disagrees that psychiatric drugs can sometimes temporarily provide relief from symptoms. However, so do illicit drugs and alcohol—which, according to Ethan Nadelmann, director of the Lindesmith Center (a drug-policy research institute) “represent a form of self-medication against physical and emotional pain among people who do not have access to psychotherapy or Prozac.”
If you want to compare apples to apples, compare psychiatric drugs to illicit drugs and alcohol. JAMA's proclamation in 2001 that “Ritalin Acts Much Like Cocaine” shouldn't have been a revelation. Thirty years ago, the World Health Organization compared Ritalin to cocaine. Why? ADHD drugs such as Ritalin, Adderall, and Dexedrine affect the same neurotransmitters as cocaine; and ADHD drugs and cocaine are both classified by the DEA as Schedule II psychostimulants (Schedule II drugs are legal drugs that have the highest potential for abuse and addiction). Researchers have also confirmed that the clinical effects of these ADHD drugs are indistinguishable from cocaine if both are similarly administered. A Primer of Drug Action (1998) notes this about the ADHD drug Dexedrine: “Individuals who have used cocaine have difficulty distinguishing between the subjective effects of 8 to 10 milligrams of cocaine and 10 milligrams of dextroamphe- tamine [Dexedrine] when both are administered intravenously.”
Many are upset to discover that SSRI drugs such as Prozac, Zoloft, and Paxil have much in common with Ecstasy. SSRIs enhance serotonin—also enhanced by Ecstasy (which increases serotonin by a somewhat different mechanism and has a quicker and more intense “pop”). Throughout the 1990s we were told by drug companies that SSRIs were neither dangerous nor habit forming. However, in 2000, Harvard Medical School psychiatrist Joseph Glenmullen reported that SSRIs are linked to neurological disorders indicating potential brain damage, and he noted: “Withdrawal syndromes—which can be debilitating—are estimated to affect up to 50% of patients.” Thus, not only is there no evidence that SSRIs (or any other psychiatric drug) restore chemical imbalances, the withdrawal effect of these drugs is actually evidence that they create chemical imbalances.
The withdrawal effects of the benzodiazapine tranquilizers such as Xanax, Ativan, or Klonopin are exactly the same as those of alcohol (e.g., shakiness, loss of appetite, muscle cramps, memory and concentration problems, insomnia, agitation, and anxiety). Not only are the clinical and withdrawal effects of benzodiazapines the same as alcohol, so are the biochemical effects, as both work on the body's GABA system.
When psychiatric drugs produce symptom relief, they work the same way illicit drugs and alcohol do: They “take the edge off.” When you are taking prescription psychotropic drugs like Ritalin, Paxil, or Xanax, or you are using illicit psychotropic drugs or alcohol, your emotional experience is dampened. Your boredom, frustration, hurt, and anger are less intense. You care less about what you are feeling and you care even less about what others are feeling. For some people, this helps them function. If you talk to an honest psychiatric drug user, an honest illicit drug user, or an honest alcohol user, you'll hear the same thing: “It worked, for a while, by taking the edge off.” However, you'll also often hear this: “Eventually, I needed more to achieve the same ends.”
Pharmaceutical companies have spent billions of dollars attempting to convince us that psychiatric drugs are just another kind of medicine and to accept their version of what's reasonable. Their version goes something like this: “While some medicines do turn out to be dangerous and other good medicines can be over-prescribed, it is extremist to say that psychiatric medications don't have their appropriate use.” This version of what's reasonable would be correct if we were talking about nonpsychiatric medications. However, the history of psychiatric drugs is far different than the history of nonpsychiatric medications. In the history of psychiatric drugs, all are ultimately found to be either (a) highly addictive, as evidenced by withdrawal; (b) highly ineffective, compared to a proper placebo; (c) highly dangerous, in terms of short-term or long-term adverse effects; (d) all of the above. When one realizes that psychiatric drugs are—chemically and clinically—in the same category as illicit drugs and alcohol, then the pharmaceutical companies' version of what's reasonable becomes unreasonable.
Calling psychiatric drugs medicine while at the same time labeling illicit drugs and alcohol as poisons is a triumph of sorts. It is a triumph of marketing over science and a triumph of injustice over compassion. It is also a triumph of denial and evasion. By this hypocritical labeling process, we can deny the devastating societal impact of a corporate hegemony that worships markets rather than life, because we've been “enabled” to evade this question: Why do increasingly more of us need to take the edge off? Z
Bruce Levine is the author of Commonsense Rebellion: Debunking Psychiatry, Confronting Society—An A to Z Guide to Rehumanizing Our Lives (New York: Continuum, 2001).