Terror in Haiti
By David Peterson at Sep 02, 2006 |
|
[E]stimates suggest that about 8000 individuals were murdered, with almost half of the perpetrators identified as political actors. Sexual abuse, especially among children, was also a frequent occurrence. [The] data suggest that 35 000 women and girls were raped during the time period examined; more than half of the victims were children. Death threats, threats of sexual violence, and threats of physical violence were also common occurrences. Criminals, the Haitian National Police (and other governmental security forces), and UN peacekeepers were the most identified perpetrators of threats of bodily harm....The frequency of human rights violations, and especially the prevalence of sexual violence against women, demands a serious and thorough response from the international community, the new Haitian government, and non-govermental organisations working in the region.
---- "Human rights abuse and other criminal violations in Port-au-Prince, Haiti: a random survey of households," Athena R. Kolbe and Dr. Royce A Hutson, The Lancet, September 2, 2006
I've just run multiple searches across several bundles of English-language news media, both U.S. and foreign.
Amazingly (to me, anyway), nobody else within the English-language print media appears to have reported the existence of The Lancet's study, other than the Jeff Heinrich byline up in Canada. (Though Heinrich's two reports did appear in multiple Canadian print dailies via the CanWest News Service.)
Not even the wire services seem to have discovered The Lancet's study.
Through September 3, this also holds true of the U.S. print media: Nothing.
Pretty remarkable. Wouldn't you say?
But---how do we explain it?
Update (September 4): Aside from the September 1 and 2 reports that circulated under Jeff Heinrich's byline via the CanWest News Service and were published in multiple Canadian print dailies, the September 4 report by Andrew Buncombe for The Independent ("Police and political groups linked to Haiti sex attacks") constitutes but the third overall to have appeared in the English-language print dailies. (Though the Buncombe also was reprinted in the September 4 Belfast Telegraph.) In short, the Kolbe – Hutson attempt to assess the grave levels of violence (including sexual violence against women along class or caste and racial lines) in post-Aristide Haiti has been barely noticed by the English-language news media. Until these past few days, I had not realized how thoroughly successful the Washington regime's democracy-building mission to Haiti has been. Not a single U.S.-based print daily--and certainly none of the majors--has published one peep about the Kolbe - Hutson study.
Update (September 8): In calling this article to my attention, a friend observes: "Finally, the Guardian covers the Lancet report on Haiti - but the focus is on alleged problems with the report rather than the violence."
"Lancet caught up in row over Haiti murders," Duncan Campbell, The Guardian, September 8, 2006
The Lancet, Vol. 368, No. 9538
September 2, 2006
DOI:10.1016/S0140-6736(06)69211-8
"Human rights abuse and other criminal violations in Port-au-Prince, Haiti: a random survey of households," Athena R. Kolbe and Royce A. Hutson (Wayne State University, School of Social Work, Thompson Home, 4756 Cass Avenue, Detroit, MI 4802, USA)
"UN peacekeepers in Haiti," Editorial, The Lancet, Vol. 368, No. 9538, September 2, 2006
"Open season on Haiti's poor, study finds: UN soldiers often identified as perpetrators," Jeff Heinrich, Montreal Gazette, September 1, 2006
"Canadian troops in Haiti accused of making death, rape threats," Jeff Heinrich, Montreal Gazette, September 2, 2006
"Police and political groups linked to Haiti sex attacks," Andrew Buncombe, The Independent, September 4, 2006
2006
“Latortue's disturbing legacy,” Ira Kurzban, Miami Herald, September 7, 2006 (as posted to the website of the Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti)
"Military police probe claims troops threatened Haitians," Jeff Heinrich, Montreal Gazette, September 7, 2006
“Author of Lancet article on Haiti investigated,” Marina Jimenez, Toronto Globe and Mail, September 7, 2006
"Lancet caught up in row over Haiti murders," Duncan Campbell, The Guardian, September 8, 2006
Institute for Justice and Democracy in Haiti (Homepage)
Canada-Haiti Action Network (Homepage)
News Focus: Haiti, UN News Center
United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (MINUSTAH) Report of the Secretary-General on the United Nations Stabilization Mission in Haiti (S/2006/592), UN Secretary-General, July 28, 2006
"The question concerning Haiti" (S/PV.5513), UN Security Council, August 15, 2006
UN Security Council Resolution 1702 (S/RES/1702), August 15, 2006
"Security Council Extends United Nations Mission in Haiti Until February 15, 2007" (SC/8811), News release, UN Security Council August 15, 2006
"Stressing crime prevention, Security Council extends UN mission in Haiti by 6 months," UN News Center, August 15, 2006
"Haiti - The Traditional Predators," Media Lens, September 11, 2006
"Terror in Haiti," ZNet, September 2, 2006
____________________________________________
Table 1. Estimated crude rate and number of victims by type of violation for greater Port-au-Prince area
Table 2. Perpetrators of human rights violations
n=5720 (1259·36 for weighed analyses). Rates are percentages (95% CI) of specified violations committed by specified group, extrapolated to the greater Port-au-Prince area. Numbers of occurrences are absolute frequencies derived from the sample. n/a=not applicable.
*Respondent only (weighted).
Table 3. Post-stratification analysis
Data are proportion of individuals in zone that were victimised during the period assessed, extrapolated to entire population for the zone (95% CI).
____________________________________________



a bit more on the islamofascists scam
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 27, 2006 11:26 AM
there new videos of ol terrorist are surfacin agin! this time terrorist look tired as if he just went do his morning jogging to stay in shape.
if you recall last video , the terrorist look like he had been vacationing
at the CIA offices..
- Truly, you can't even find a motive
- for their release other than to allege
- the World is under threat to convert - to islam..
<--- scary islamo fascist
----------------------------------------------------
A a third genereration CIA fascist hiding under the mask
of islamoterorismofascism..
boo be very scared, islamofascist are out to get you!
Reply this comment
I looked a bit..
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 06, 2006 23:17 PM
May be the states would not have to make cuts in education if the country was not neglected by the reps.. i mean, reaaly and like if its not enough Bush himself make cuts to the education structures..
What this tell you rudy?, it tell you that the education structures is eroding because your political elite ( reps-and dems) don't care if the next generations get educated; in other words all these rich guy used the public system to get rich and now that they had success they avoid paying their taxes..whats was good for them is no longer good for others, the poor and the defavorized..
An education system should imposes a better than "rudimentary funding " for schools and higher standards of education should also be imposed..otherwise the american population may become mental rudistes
Reply this comment
Why don't you look to see
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 06, 2006 17:43 PM
Reply this comment
Christian Zionism?,
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 06, 2006 14:02 PM
Reply this comment
Reply "You do realize that by" (2006-09-05 23:22)
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 06, 2006 11:16 AM
Friends:
When inserting images, please be sure to label them clearly. Otherwise, as in the case above, no one will be able to tell them apart. (I know. Because I can't see any difference.)
Thanks.
(Also see the Jerusalem Declaration on Christian Zionism.)David Peterson
Chicago, USA
Reply this comment
Reply to "Media and Engineered Historical Amnesia" (2006-09-06)
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 06, 2006 11:04 AM
Kelvin:
I myself barely have any exposure to the British media. And then just the print media, which can be accessed via the Internet.
But trivialize is an apt term. Infantilize, too.
What kind of history of the present can possibly result from practices shared by the likes of the McDonalds Corporation?
David Peterson
Chicago, USA
Reply this comment
Re: You do realize that by
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 05, 2006 23:22 PM
Rudy, wrote You do realize that by tacitly "siding" with Serbia you are supporting a national socialist regime, right? I dont see why socialist are a threat..also I don't stand with conspiracists, IMO the serb did not intend nor commit genocide. The US does commit genocide on a daily basis.Take Vietnam as an example, people are still dying from the horror commited by the americans there. Rudy, Bin laden denied any involvement with 9/11. He was never charged, arrested and most importantly, why would he deny 9/11? If he was the conspirator, WTC would look good on his terrorist résumé.. so why deny it? You have to look at the possibility that it is not him the responsible and consider that may be someone else did it, mainly to secure oil and economic supremacy against emerging power such as China and the EU.. Rudy, I am sorry, i don't believ the latest Al-Quaida video. It look US made.. I dont believe Bush when he says Bin Laden is comparable to Hitler for the following reasons: Bin Laden does not have an army and does not seat on a propaganda machine. Muslim do not recognizing as a leader. Bush seats on an army and propaganda machine very same as Hitler did, Hitler war was on terrorist, so does Bush.. Bin Laden does not occupies countries.. Hitler occopied europe and the ME... Bush is occupying OIL rich countries and OIL is BEING stolen from these countries.. so if its not Bin laden who did it consider that it could be Bin LaBush.. (note, every day Bush speeches are centered against a ISLAMIST threat that is not there or is not compatible with what arabs reports.. even leia mouammar cannot find islamist but nationalist.
No need to look in afghanistan or the world for the terrorist of 9/11 , your guy does too many lies not to be the guilty one.
Bin LaBush SCARIEST OF ALL TERRORIST KNOWN, BEWARE OF LIES..
Reply this comment
Reply to "It's amazing that you" (2006-09-05 17:18)
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 05, 2006 22:55 PM
Friends:
On February 7, 1986, in the face of massive popular protests, President-for-Life Jean-Claude Duvalier & Co. (this outfit having taken some 99.98 of the affirmative vote in a referendum held as recently as the previous July, the sole issue having been whether JCD should retain the authority “President-for-Life” for life) fled Port-au-Prince via a U.S. Air Force transport for France.
Some 18 years later, over the weekend of February 28-29, 2004, the democratically-elected President Jean-Bertrand Aristide was kidnapped from the presidential residence by American operatives and whisked out of Port-au-Prince via a U.S. Air Force transport for the Central African Republic, after a relatively small group of well-armed mercenaries had marched on the capital gunning for Aristide, and Aristide, under pressure from both Paris and Washington, finally relented. By the end of the same weekend, the UN Security Council unanimously adopted Resolution 1529. (Also see SC/8015.)
A reasonable question might be: Between February 1986, and today, early September, 2006, has Haiti's Government exercised a greater level of influence over domestic life in the USA? Or has the U.S. Government exercised a greater level of influence over domestic life in Haiti?
David Peterson
Chicago, USA
Reply this comment
You do realize that by
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 05, 2006 21:48 PM
Reply this comment
Reply to "Media and Lancet report" (2006-09-05 08:39)
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 05, 2006 18:20 PM
Kelvin:
Ran some quick (though perfectly comparable) searches of various bundles of news media for mentions of (a) ‘Haiti' and ‘Lancet', on the one hand, and (b) ‘crocodile hunter' or ‘Steve Irwin', on the other.
Under Category (A), we still find nothing more than the Jeff Heinrich-bylined reports as well as Andrew Buncombe's. (For these details, see the Blog.)Under Category (B), we find quite a few more.
(Can compile some kind of rough estimate of the actual disparity between (A) and (B), if it would help drive home the point. Though this should be unnecessary.)
No offense to the gentleman from Australia whose sudden death in an accident at the age of 44 has come as such surprising news to so many people.
But findings such as these do make for an instructive comparison.
Don't you think?
David Peterson
Chicago, USA
Reply this comment
It's amazing that you
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 05, 2006 17:18 PM
Reply this comment
saucy US
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 05, 2006 13:07 PM
Reply this comment
US and Haiti
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 04, 2006 12:47 PM
Reply this comment
This could help rudy..
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 04, 2006 12:26 PM
Reply this comment
rudy
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 04, 2006 11:51 AM
rudy wrote: The fact is, Papa Doc and Baby Doc, the democratic presidents for life, as they called themselves, were close allies of Castro and Cuba.
where do you have your sources?
President Aristides won the first elections in Haiti. Twice Terrorist paid and sponsored by the US overtwrew the democracy.. Papa doc and baby doc were dictator armed and sUpported by the US and by France..Rudy you must be aware of that the US is the biggest sponsor of Fascism, it has been supressing democracy for over 50 years.. David , Brad here some Créole language, you can use when encounter a haitian person( just to look cool..) Comment ouillé ? ( comment ça va? ) Mam boolé.. ( ça va bien)
Reply this comment
What in that post or the
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 04, 2006 10:46 AM
Reply this comment
Reply to "Haiti and U.S. Terror" (2006-09-03 13:23)
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 04, 2006 00:11 AM
Mfbrad:
One of the endlessly amazing facets of this whole thing is the fact that The Lancet's important report has passed virtually unreported in the English-speaking world. Certainly in the U.S. media.
David Peterson
Chicago, USA
Reply this comment
Hati and US terror
By Kissenger, Clark at Sep 03, 2006 13:23 PM
Reply this comment
Comment On This Blog Post See All Comments (18)