To:

Zcom_simple
Home » ZMag » David Swanson » The Bomb
Fc-zmag-sep10-small

September 2010

Volume 23, Number 9
Printable PDF File
Commentary

BEHIND THE SCENES
Journal of 23rd Year
Z Staff


WAR
Losing in Afghanistan
Marjorie Cohn


FOG WATCH
Global (In)justice
Edward Herman


COURT WATCH
Whistleblowers & Court
Stephen Bergstein


DEMOCRACY DEFICIT
U.S. Buys Press
Eva Golinger


BEHIND THE CURTAIN
Tea Party Tale
Don Monkerud


CONSERVATIVE WATCH
New Apocalypse
Bill Berkowitz


Activism

MOVEMENT BUILDING
USSF 2010
Chris Spannos


LOCAL OPPOSITION
Guam Build-Up
Seth Kershner


Features

AIRSPACE
Drones Over America
Mike Reizman


MILITARY ACTIVITY
AFRICOM
Stephen Roblin


MEDIA STUDIES
Paper of Power?
Florian Zollmann


Reviews

BOOK REVIEW
Politics of Genocide
Rick Rozoff


BOOK REVIEW
Anatomy of Epidemic
Bruce Levine


BOOK REVIEW
Epic Recession
Suzi Weissman


BOOK REVIEW
The Bomb
David Swanson


BOOK REVIEW
Korean War
Jeremy Kuzmarov


BOOK REVIEW
FDR & New Deal
John Pietaro


Zaps

FREE LISTINGS
Zaps - 09/10
Various Contributors


NOTE: Z Magazine subscribers and sustainers have access to all Z Magazine articles here and in the archive. The latest Z Magazine articles available to everyone are listed in the Free Articles box at the top of the table of contents, and are starred in the list below. Questions? e-mail Z Magazine Online.

The Bomb

By David Swanson
PDF Version
Printer Friendly Version
September 2010
 Change Text Size a- | A+

Book by Howard Zinn; San Francisco, City Lights, 2010, 100 pp.

The late Howard Zinn's new book The Bomb is a brilliant dissection of some of the central myths of our militarized society. Those who've read A Terrible Mistake: The Murder of Frank Olson and the CIA's Secret Cold War Experiments by H.P. Albarelli Jr. know that this is a year for publishing stories of horrible things that the United States has done to French towns. In that case, Albarelli describes the CIA administering LSD to an entire town, with deadly results. In The Bomb, Zinn describes the U.S. military making its first use of napalm by dropping it over another French town, burning anyone and anything it touched. Zinn was in one of the planes, taking part in this horrendous crime.

In mid-April 1945, the war in Europe was essentially over. Everyone knew it was ending. There was no military reason (if that's not an oxymoron) to attack the Germans stationed near Royan, France, much less to burn the French men, women, and children in the town to death. The British had already destroyed the town in January, similarly bombing it because of its vicinity to German troops, in what was widely called a tragic mistake. This tragic mistake was rationalized as an inevitable part of war, just as were the horrific firebombings that successfully reached German targets, just as was the later bombing of Royan with napalm. Zinn blames the Supreme Allied Command for seeking to add a "victory" in the final weeks of a war already won. He blames the local military commanders' ambitions. He blames the American Air Force's desire to test a new weapon. And he blames everyone involved—which must include himself—for "the most powerful motive of all: the habit of obedience, the universal teaching of all cultures, not to get out of line, not even to think about that which one has not been assigned to think about, the negative motive of not having either a reason or a will to intercede."

When Zinn returned from the war in Europe, he expected to be sent to the war in the Pacific, until he saw and rejoiced at seeing the news of the atomic bomb dropped on Hiroshima, 65 years ago last month. Only years later did Zinn come to understand the inexcusable crime of the greatest proportions that was the dropping of nuclear bombs in Japan, actions similar in some ways to the final bombing of Royan. The war with Japan was already over, the Japanese were seeking peace and willing to surrender. Japan asked only that it be permitted to keep its emperor, a request that was later granted. But, like napalm, the nuclear bombs were weapons that needed testing. The second bomb, dropped on Nagasaki, was a different sort of bomb that also needed testing. President Harry Truman wanted to demonstrate nuclear bombs to the world and especially to Russia. And he wanted to end the war with Japan before Russia became part of it. The horrific form of mass murder he employed was in no way justifiable.

Zinn also goes back to dismantle the reasons the United States was in the war to begin with. The United States, England, and France were imperial powers supporting each other's international aggressions in places like the Philippines. They opposed the same from Germany and Japan, but not aggression itself. Most of America's tin and rubber came from the Southwest Pacific. The United States made clear for years its lack of concern for the Jews being attacked in Germany. It also demonstrated its lack of opposition to racism through its treatment of African and Japanese Americans. Franklin D. Roosevelt described fascist bombing campaigns over civilian areas as "inhuman barbarity," but then did the same on a much larger scale to German cities, which was followed up by the destruction on an unprecedented scale of Hiroshima and Nagasaki—actions that came after years of dehumanizing the Japanese. Zinn points out that "Life Magazine showed a picture of a Japanese person burning to death and commented: 'This is the only way'."

Zinn points out with his trademark clarity how the use of the word "we" blends governments together with peoples and serves to equate our own people with our military, while we demonize the people of other lands because of actions by their governments. The Bomb suggests a better way to think about such matters and firmly establishes that what the U.S. military is doing today parallels the crimes of the past and shares their dishonorable motivations. The bad wars have a lot in common with so-called "good wars" about which there was little, if anything, good. Zinn did far more in his life for peace than for war and more for peace than just about anybody else.

Z
David Swanson is the author of Daybreak: Undoing the Imperial Presidency and Forming a More Perfect Union.
Loading_border