Volume , Number 0
There are no articles.
CommentaryThere are no articles.
Culture
No Nukes
Michael Steinberg
Hotel Satire
Lydia Sargent
Troop Maneuvers
David Rosen
Domestic Policy
Jack Rasmus
Music Review
John Pietaro
Reunion
Travis Mclaughlin
Fog Watch
Edward Herman
Twentieth Anniversary
Barbara Ehrenreich
Science
Martin Donohoe
Wiretapping
Marjorie Cohn
Foreign Policy
Noam Chomsky
Gay & Lesbian Community Notes
Michael Bronski
Media Matters
Dave Brichoux
Caravan for Peace
Paul Bloom
Environment
Jon Berg
Interview
David Barsamian
Cities
Jay Arena
Features
There are no articles.
ZapsThere are no articles.
NOTE: Z Magazine subscribers and sustainers have access to all Z Magazine articles here and in the archive. The latest Z Magazine articles available to everyone are listed in the Free Articles box at the top of the table of contents, and are starred in the list below. Questions? e-mail Z Magazine Online.
The Silenced Majority
YOU MAY not have noticed, but 50,000 U.S. coal miners were on strike for
four months this spring and summer 1989. The 10-state strike featured the
unprecedented mass application of nonviolent civil disobedience to a labor
struggle: Thousands of miners and family members have been arrested for
peacefully blocking mine entrances. Troops have been called in; they have,
in some instances, fired on the strikers.
It is possible to read the papers with some diligence and completely miss
the coal miners strike. Meanwhile, the papers I read gave front- page
coverage and daily updates of the Soviet coal miners strike. I do not
grudge a bit of this coverage to the brave miners of Siberia; there were
more of them (100,000) and they inhabit a place that has until recently
fancied itself a dictatorship of the proletariat. In fact, the Russian
strike gave us an idea of what decent labor coverage might be like if the
American media were to attempt it: the workers demands were presented
sympathetically; the larger ramifications of the strike were duly analyzed;
and individual strike leaders were profiled in an appealing, human-interest
fashion.
The eclipse of the American coal miners reflects the medias usual preference
for labor insurgency in foreign ideally, communist, societiesa preference
stunningly illustrated by the ecstatic coverage granted to Solidarity in
1981, just as the American flight controllers were being ground under the
heel of capital. But it also reflects an entirely local phenomenon: the
disappearance of the American working classfrom the media, from intellectual
concern, or more generally, from the mind of the American middle class.
A quick definition: By working class I mean not only industrial workers
in hard-hats, but all those people who are not professionals, managers,
or entrepreneurs; who work for wages rather than salaries; and who spend
their working hours variously lifting, bending, driving, monitoring, keyboarding,
cleaning, providing physical care for others, loading, unloading, cooking,
serving, etc. The working class so defined comprises 60 to 70 percent of
the U.S. population.
By middle class I mean the professional middle class, the professional-managerial
class, or what intellectuals often call the new class and Michael Albert
calls the coordinator class. This group includes the journalists, professors,
media executives, etc. who are responsible, in a day-to-day sense, for
what we do or do not see in the media, read about, or understand to be
an issue. The middle class so defined amounts to no more than 20 percent
of the U.S. population.
So when I say the working class is disappearing I do not mean just a particular
minority group favored, for theoretical reasons, by leftists. I mean the
American majority. And I am laying the blame not only on the corporate
sponsors of the media, who undoubtedly prefer to have us think that everyone
is either a capitalist or a consumer, but on many less wealthy and powerful
people. Media people for example. People who are, in their lifestyles and
expectations, not too different from myself, and possibly also you.
The American working class has never received publicity in proportion to
its numbers. It did, however, enjoy a brief modishness in the 1970s, following
its discovery by the media in 1969. This discovery was in many ways parallel
to the discovery of poverty six years earlier: A previously unsuspected
group was unveiled, with great fanfare, on the covers of the national newsmagazines,
examined in television specials, and seized upon by academics. As with
the poor, the discovery of the working class was grievously flawed by the
prejudices and preconceptions of the discoverers (on which more in a minute).
But for a few years at least, the working class enjoyed the attention of
Hollywood (The Deer Hunter, Blue Collar, Saturday Night Fever, etc.) and
of journalists and academics (who produced dozens of books and articles
on work in America, the neglected majority, and so forth.)
Then in the 1980s the working class dropped from sight. Hollywood lost
interest, and on television there are only three sitcoms, as far as I can
tell, to remind us that every family is not supported by a doctor-lawyer
team. Joann Mort of ACTWU has documented the precipitous decline of labor
coverage in the newspapers, leaving the labor reporting that does go on
increasingly in the hands of the business section.
In academia, the decline of the working class has been, if anything, even
more complete. As a friend explained to me, speaking of his academic colleagues,
class is out of style. In their rush to shake off Marxist orthodoxy,
many academic intellectuals have simply dropped class as a relevant category.
Gender is still of some interest, though I must admit it is hard for me
to tell what is going on anymore in the ever-so-arch, pun- happy discourse
of the postmodern professoriate.
So it is possible for a middle class person today to read the papers, watch
television, even go to college, without suspecting that America has any
inhabitants other than white-collar operatives and, of course, the annoyingly
persistent black underclass. The producers of public affairs talk shows
do not blush to serve up four upper-income professionals (all, incidentally,
white, male, and conservative) to ponder the minimum wage or the possible
need for health insurance. Never, needless to say, an uninsured breadwinner
or an actual recipient of the minimum wage. Working class people are likely
to cross the screen only as witnesses to crimes or sports events, never
as commentators oreven when their own lives are under discussionas experts.
Most contemporary fiction shows a similar narrowness. A typical quality
novel of recent vintage will explore the relationships and reveries of
people who live in large houses and employ at least one servant to manage
all those details of daily living that are extraneous to the plot. E.L.
Doctorow has observed that when a novel featuring other sorts of peoplepoor
or working classdoes come along, it is usually judged to be political
in intent, meaning that it does not qualify as art.
The disappearance of the working class reflectsand reinforcesthe long-standing
cultural insularity of the professional middle class. Why did the working
class, or the poor, have to be discovered in the first place? From whose
vantage point were they missing? If anything, the natural solipsism of
the professional middle class has increased with the class polarizing trends
of the 1980s. Compared to say a decade ago, the classes are less likely
to mix in college (with the decline of financial aid), in residential neighborhoods
(with the gluttonous rise in real estate prices), or even in the malls
(with the now almost universal segmentation of the retail industry into
upscale and downscale components). Only the homeless disturb the middle
classs contemplation of itself and its self-imageswhich is to say, the
poor can get attention only by going outdoors and literally lying down
in the path of their betters.
In the absence of real contact or communication, stereotypes march on unchallenged,
prejudices easily substitute for knowledge. The most intractable stereotype
is of the working class (which is, in imagination, only white) as a collection
of reactionaries and bigotsas reflected, for example, in the use of the
terms hard-hat or redneck as class slurs. Middle class leftists are
by no means immune from this prejudice, and suffer immensely from their
supposed rejection at the hands of the working class.
The truth is that, statistically and collectively, the working class is
far more reliably liberal than the professional middle class. It was more,
not less, opposed to the war in Vietnam. It is more, not less, disposed
to vote for a Democrat for president (and with a class gap that is usually
many points larger than the gender gap.) And thanks to the careful, quantitative
studies of Canadian historian Richard F. Hamilton, we know that the white
working class (at least outside the south) is no more racist, and by some
measures less so, than the white professional class.
Even deeper than the stereotype of the hard-hat bigot lies the middle class
suspicion that the working class is dumb, inarticulate, and mindlessly
loyal to archaic values. In the entertainment media, for example, the working
class is usually a setting for macho exhibitionism (from Saturday Night
Fever to, in cameo, Working Girl) or mental impairment (Married With Children).
Mainstream sociologists have reinforced this prejudice with their emphasis
on working class parochialism, as, for example, in this quote from a
1976 beginning sociology textbook: Their limited education, reading habits
and associations isolate the lower class...and this ignorance, together
with their class position, makes them suspicious of [the] middle-and upper-class
experts and do-gooders...
On the left, these prejudices often manifest themselves in a reluctance
to feature working class people in conferences and other sorts of public
events. For example, when someone suggested that a coal miner be invited
to speak at an upcoming left gathering, the objection was immediately raised
that some (white) coal miners are racists. No doubt they are. But if the
proposal had been to invite, say, an economist, I doubt that anyone would
have made the reasonable objection that some economists are racists.
Similarly, the proposal of a lower class participant of any color is
likely to elicit the question: But is he or she articulate? Again, middle
class people do not raise this question in the case of, say, economists.
The assumption that the working class is nonverbal or verbally deprived
does not, of course, encourage meaningful communication between the classes.
Finally there is a level of prejudice which grows out of middle class moralism
about matters of taste. All privileged classes seek to differentiate themselves
from the less-privileged through the ways they dress, eat, entertain themselves,
and so on; and tend to see their own choices in these matters as inherently
wiser, better, and more aesthetically inspired. In middle class stereotype,
the white working class, for example, is addicted to cigarettes, Budweiser,
polyester, and network television. (In part this is true, and it is true
in part because Bud is cheaper than Dos Equis and polyester is cheaper
than linen.) Furthermore, in the middle class view, polyester, etc., is
tackya common code word for lower class. Health concerns, plus a certain
reverence for the natural in matters of food and fiber, enfuse these
middle class prejudices with a high- minded tone of moral indignation.
I do not raise these concerns to stir up guilt or with the idea of reinstating
the working class as the agent of revolution in the classical Marxist
sense. Guilt is an ugly emotion which has led to much mischief on the left.
And as for being the agent of revolutionor whatever large tasks middle
class intellectuals would like to assign itI think the working class has
shouldered this theoretical burden for far too long.
But I am alarmed by what seems to me to be the growing parochialism of
the professional middle classliving in its own social and residential
enclaves, condemned to hear only the opinions of its own members (or, of
course, of the truly rich), and cut off from the lives and struggles and
insights of the American majority. This parochialism is insidiously self-reinforcing:
The less we know about them, the more likely we are to cling to our
stereotypesor forget them altogether.
This parochialism afflicts many people in the middle class leftsometimes
even those who most loudly trumpet Marxist rhetoricas well as middle class
liberals, conservatives, and so forth. It does not make those who suffer
from it bad people. It does not invalidate them as social activists or
agents of change. But it does deprive them. The one clear price of being
cut off from the majority is, for the time being, only ignorance.
Z Magazine Archive
Announcements
OCCUPY TOGETHER - Occupy Together is the unofficial hub for the various occupations springing up across the country in solidarity with Occupy Wall St. Towns and cities worldwide are participating.
Contact: http://www.occupytogether.org/.
MAY DAY - May 1 is May Day, also International Workers Day, celebrating the successful fight of workers for rights such as the eight-hour workday. A General Strike is called for May Day by many groups, and events are planned worldwide.
Contact: http://maydayunited.org/; http://www.may1.info/; info@maydayunited.org.
LABOR - The 2012 Labor Notes Conference, themed Solidarity for the 99%, will be held May 4-6, in Chicago. Thousands of union members, officers, and grassroots labor activists will attend the event, which features workshops, meetings and organizing opportunities.
Contact: 313-842-6262; http:// labornotes.org/conference.
MARIJUANA MARCH - On the first Saturday of May (this year: May 5) marijuana legalization activists will hold informational and educational events, rallies and marches in over 300 cities around the world.
Contact: http://globalcannabismarch.com; http://cannabis.wikia.com.
AMERICAN MUSLIMS - KinderUSA will celebrate its 10th Anniversary with a Fundraising Banquet Dinner in Los Angeles on May 5. The keynote speaker will be Norman Finkelstein. KinderUSA was founded as a group of concerned humanitarians and physicians, and has become a leading American Muslim charity organization helping families through health development and emergency relief.
Contact: http://www.kinder usa.org/.
SEXUAL VIOLENCE - SWAN (Service Women’s Action Network) will present Truth and Justice: The 2012 Summit on Military Sexual Violence in Washington, D.C. on May 8. The conferences will give survivors the opportunity to share their stories with congressmembers, policy experts and the general public; with key panels by military law and policy experts on major topics involving military sexual violence and survivors’ access to justice.
Contact: http://truthandjustice summit.org/.
MEDIA - The Alliance for Community Media Youth Summit 2012 will be held May 8 at Pierce College in Philadelphia, PA. The summit will consist of four one-day symposia that provide a public forum for discussion about media and news literacy in America. Participants will include educators, community leaders, media professionals, journalists, nonprofit leaders, policymakers and students.
Contact: http://www.allcommunitymedia.org.
MOMS/BOMBS - Moms Against Bombs and the Ground Zero Center for Nonviolent Action will honor the long history of women’s resistance to injustice, war and nuclear weapons on May 12. A full day of activities is planned, including Orientation to the Trident Nuclear Weapons System, Nonviolence Training, Action Planning and Preparation, Mother’s Day Proclamation for Peace, and a Vigil and Nonviolent Direct Action at the Bangor Trident Submarine Base.
Contact: Anne Hall, 206- 545-3562, annehall@familyhealing.com; gznonviolencenews@yahoo.com; www.gzcenter.org.
MOTHER’S DAY/PEACE - The Mother’s Day Walk for Peace began in 1996 for families who had lost their children to violence. On a day that celebrates mothers and children, the Walk became a place for families and friends to feel support and love with thousands of others who pledge their commitment to peace.
The day has also become a way for thousands of people to financially support the work of the Louis Brown Peace Institute. Mother’s Day is May 13.
Contact: http://www.kintera.org/faf/home/; http://www.ldb peaceinstitute.org/.
BRECHT FORUM - The Beginning Is Near: An Evening with Michael Moore & Cornel West, a special benefit for the Brecht Forum, will be held May 18 at Hunter College in New York City.
Contact: https://brechtforum.org.
LABOR - The Pacific Northwest Labor History Association’s 44th annual conference, A Century of Bread and Roses, is scheduled for May 18-20 in Tacoma, WA.
Contact: PNLHA, 2402-6888 Station Hill Drive, Burnaby, BC, V3N 4X5; 604-540-0245; pnlha@shaw.ca; www.pnlha.org.
HOMELESSNESS - PM Press and First Presbyterian Church will host author Summer Brenner at the Conference on Homelessness on May 19 in Palo Alto, CA.
Contact: First Presbyterian Church, 1140 Cowper Street, Palo Alto, VA 94301; http://www.pmpress.org/.
NATO/G8 - The Coalition Against NATO/G8 War & Poverty Agenda is organizing protests at the NATO and G8 meetings being held in Chicago, May 19-21. A legal, permitted, family-friendly march and rally are planned for May 19. An Occupy Chicago month-long occupation is being planned to begin May 1. The Network for a Nato-Free Future and American Friends Service Committee will also be hosting a Counter-Summit for Peace and Economic Justice May 18-19 at People’s Church in Chicago.
Contact: http://cang8.wordpress.com/about/; http://www.natofreefuture.org/.
ANARCHY FEST - A month-long Festival of Anarchy is scheduled for May in Montreal. The festival includes The Montreal Anarchist Bookfair (May 19-20).
Contact: http://www.radical montreal.com/;http://www.anarchist bookfair.ca/.
TRUTHDIG - Truthdig.com will be gathering May 20-25 in New Mexico with other concerned people to assess current prospects for progressive change. Speakers include Dennis Kucinich and Chris Hedges.
Contact: http://www.truthdig.com/event/santafe.
FEMINIST SCI-FI - The feminist science fiction convention WisCon 36 is scheduled for May 25-28 in Madison, Wisconsin, featuring discussion and debate of sci-fi/fantasy ideas relating to feminism, gender, race and class.
Contact: WisCon, c/o SF3, PO Box 1624, Madison, WI 53701; concom35@wiscon.info; www.wiscon.info.
MULTICULTURE - The 25th Annual National Conference on Race & Ethnicity in American Higher Education (NCORE) holds its annual conference May 29 -June 2 in New York City.
Contact: Southwest Center for Human Relations Studies, 3200 Marshall Avenue, Suite 290, Norman, OK 73072; 405- 325-3694; www.ncore.ou.edu.
BIKING - Bikes Not Bombs is holding its 24th annual Bike-A-Thon and Green Roots Festival in Boston, MA on June 3, with several bike rides scheduled, music, exhibitors and more.
Contact: Bikes Not Bombs, 284 Amory St., Jamaica Plain, MA 02130; 617-522-0222; mail@bikesnotbombs.org; www.bikesnotbombs.org.
RADIO - The 37th Annual Community Radio Conference is scheduled for June 13-16 in Houston, TX with discussions and workshops.
Contact: National Federation of Community Broadcasters, 1970 Broadway, Suite 1000, Oakland, CA 94612; 510-451 -8200; conference@nfcb.org; www.nfcb.org.
PEOPLE’S SUMMIT - The People’s Summit for Social and Environmental Justice during Rio+20 is an event by global civil society that will take place between the 15 and the 23 of June at Flamengo, in Rio de Janeiro—alongside the United Nations Conference on Sustainable Development (UNCSD), Rio+20.
Contact: contato@rio2012. org.br; http://cupuladospovos.org.br/en/.
ADC CONFERENCE - The American-Arab Anti-Discrimination Committee (ACD) holds its annual conference June 21-24 in Washington, DC, with panel discussions and workshops on civil rights, media, the Mideast, etc.
Contact: ADC, 1732 Wisconsin Ave., NW, Washington DC, 20007; 202-244-2990; convention@adc.org; www.adc.org/convention.
MEDIA - The 14th annual Allied Media Conference will be held June 28-July 1 at Wayne State University in Detroit, MI. Participatory workshops and skillshares will emphasize DIY alternative media to advance visions of a just and creative world.
Contact: Allied Media Projects, 4126 Third St., Detroit, MI 48201; www.alliedmediacon ference.org.
LA RAZA - The annual National Council of La Raza (NCLR) Conference is scheduled for July 7-10 in Las Vegas, with workshops, presentations and panel discussions.
Contact: NCLR Headquarters Office, Raul Yzaguirre Building, 1126 16th Street, NW, Washington, DC 20036; 202-785-1670; www.nclr.org.
PEACESTOCK - On July 14 the 10th Annual Peace- stock: A Gathering for Peace will take place at Windbeam Farm in Hager City, WI. Peacestock (formerly “Pigstock”) is a mixture of music, speakers, and community for peace. The event is sponsored by Veterans for Peace, Chapter 115 and has a peace-themed agenda.
Contact: Bill Habedank, 1913 Grandview Ave., Red Wing, MN 55066; 651-388-7733; billhabedank@yahoo.com; http://www.peacestockvfp.org.
POPULAR ECONOMICS - The Center for Popular Economics is holding its 2012 Summer Institute July 23-27 at Columbia University in New York City. No background in economics is needed for this intensive training. This year’s theme is Economics for the 99%.
Contact: Center for Popular Economics, PO Box 785 Amherst, MA 01004; 413-545-0743; programs@populareconomics.org; www.populareconomics.org.
CUBA/PASTORS - The 23rd annual Pastors for Peace Friendship Caravan to Cuba is scheduled for
July1-July 31. Volunteers will travel across the U.S and Canada collecting aid and educating about the unjust blockade against Cuba, before an orientation in Texas July 15-18, followed by an education program in Cuba July 21-29, and finally a return back to the U.S. People can participate by attending or hosting local events, donating materials, or sponsoring a traveler.
Contact: IFCO/Pastors for Peace, 418 W. 145th St., New York, NY 10031; 212-926- 5757; cucaravan@igc.org; www.pastorsforpeace.org.
COMMUNITY MEDIA - The Alliance for Community Media 2012 National Conference is scheduled for July 31-August 2 in Chicago. Hands-on workshops and skillshares will be offered by this grassroots coalition of community media groups. This year’s theme is Collaborate!
Contact: ACM, 1760 Old Meadow Road, Suite 500, McLean, VA 22102; www.alliancecm.org.
VETERANS - Veterans for Peace is holding the 27th annual convention August 8-12 in Miami, FL. This year’s theme is, Liberating the Americas: Lessons from Latin America and the Caribbean.
Contact: Veterans For Peace, 216 S. Meramec Ave., St. Louis, MO 63105; 314-725-6005; www.vfpnationalconvention.org
COMMUNITIES - The Communities Conference is a networking and learning opportunity for co-operative or communal lifestyles, with workshops, events and entertainment; scheduled for August 31-September 3 at the Twin Oaks Community in Louisa, Virginia.
Contact: Twin Oaks Communities Conference, 138 Twin Oaks Road, Louisa, VA 23093; 540-894-5126; conference@ twinoaks.org; www.communitiesconference.org.


