avatar
Easy To Kill Those Who are “Not One of Us”


While walking the halls in juvenile prison each week, there is an eery sensation of bearing witness to childhoods sent up in flames. Peering deeply into the ashen masks worn by these young offenders, I look for vital signs indicating it isn’t too late for an infusion of hope.

It’s not that faith is a foreign concept but too many have already learned the risks of optimism. For some, too much damage has already been done to imagine anything different.

Many were abused and neglected by parents, guardians or society in general and can recount unthinkable tales of violation in a flat affect and cadence of someone reciting the phone book. Their innocence has been burned out of them.

My mission on most days is to ignite a spark from the embers in hopes they will envision another self, another life–as someone worthy of respect. Often I leave feeling a failure and swear not to return. But I do anyway.

Most of the youth I work with are poor blacks or Latinos hailing from neighborhoods that most folks I know have never even driven through–and wouldn’t even consider it. I don’t recall having ever met a young inmate from Bellmeade or Forest Hills (wealthy Nashville suburbs). It’s not surprising considering that African Americans while comprising 13% of the National population inhabit 53 % of prisons. This figure clearly illustrates the racial disparities prevalent in our criminal justice system.

As I drive away, I am reminded of a classic example of racial injustice: Abu-Ali Abdhur Rahman, a 52 year old death-row inmate at Riverbend Prison in Nashville. Like many of the young offenders I meet, Abu-Ali’s childhood was snuffed out at an early age. In addition to various physical and sexual tortures, Abu-Ali’s parents used his person as an ashtray (literally) extinguishing cigarettes on his 4 year-old body and beating him until he ceased to scream. The abuses were countless and hideous, and like many of the incarcerated youth I encounter, his pleas for help were ignored.

Abu-Ali developed severe emotional and psychological disorders over the years and began running away at age eight. By the time he was a teenager, he lived in a correctional institute where, once again, he was subjected to sexual abuse–further adding to his mental instability, Again, Abu-Ali received no help from authorities.

Fast forward to 1986: As an adult, Abu-Ali was involved with a vigilante group whose mission was to stop the selling of drugs to children in the black community. The group planned to accomplish this task by intimidating local drug dealers. The misguided mission went awry and a known drug dealer, was stabbed to death.

Although Abu-Ali was present at the crime and clearly involved, no evidence was presented to prove him guilty of first-degree murder–for which he received a death sentence. Physical blood evidence indicates that Abu-Ali did not commit the murder and although this was known by State Prosecutor, John Zimmermann, it was never presented to the jury.

Abu-Ali, a poor, mentally ill black man, without financial means relied on Allen Boyd, his former employer and co-member of SGM, to pay for legal fees. After several failed legal relationships, Abu-Ali was represented by trial attorneys, Sumpter Camp and Lionel Barrett who later admitted they did absolutely no preparation on this capitol murder case until a week before trial. They called no witnesses for Abu-Ali and failed to explore his lengthy history of mental illness. Although the State prosecutor was aware of the mental illness and abuse, the jury was never given a social history of the defendant.

The judge presiding over Abu-Ali’s trial concluded that the attorney’s performance was substandard. And in the last year and a half, 8 out of 12 jurors signed sworn affidavits saying had they known any of the evidence or mitigating circumstances, they may not have given the death penalty.

For many of us, it is difficult to comprehend how under such spurious circumstances, Abu-Ali’s appeals for life are denied. But it is only difficult to imagine if you are accustomed to fairness. As a middle-class white woman I expect to be dealt with fairly and justly. Many of us do.

Some suggest the case is complicated but the simple questions aren’t being asked: If Abu-Ali were white, educated and middle-class, would he have received the same substandard legal treatment? If Abu-Ali were a prominent member of the community would not the clear lack of evidence and ineffective counsel create a public outcry so deafening that our governor’s only choice would be to grant clemency?

If we are honest, the answers are clear. Watching television teaches us it is far easier to kill those who are “not one of us”.

When young offenders ask me if I believe things will ever be any different , I wince. Some of them already know that for those sitting in the judges chambers, the prisons are full of those who are “not one of us”. I look them squarely in the eye and say: “justice always prevails in the end”. They rarely believe me and unfortunately, neither do I.

If you would like to help stop this execution contact Susan Mcbride at: shmcbride@comcast.net

Molly Secours is a writer/speaker/activist and a contributing writer to the book “Should America Pay: Slavery and the Raging Debate on Reparations”. She can be reached at mollmaud@earthlink.net

“Only when we cease to scream with activity can we hear the gentle murmur of peace within.”

mollmaud@earthlink.net Po Box 68534 Nashville TN 37206

http://www.steveconn.com/molly/index.html (bio page) http://www.steveconn.com/molly/articles/index.html (links to articles) http://www.zmag.org/bios/homepage.cfm?authorID=156 (znet articles)

Leave a comment